Scameras misconduct!
Missing “construction” zone reported!
Use a dash cam when in these zones, truck version allows savings shots to bust scameras vendors breaking the law.
Summary of News10NBC Investigation on DOT Speeding Ticket Dismissals
Quick Overview
In a recent investigation by News10NBC, discrepancies in photographic evidence and late notification of speeding tickets have led to the dismissal of numerous Department of Transportation (DOT) speeding tickets issued to drivers on I-490 in Rochester, New York. The investigation highlights concerns over the enforcement of speed limits in work zones and the accuracy of the ticketing process.
Key Points
- High Volume of Tickets: Over 25,000 speeding tickets were issued in just 24 days, averaging more than 1,000 tickets daily, significantly higher than the statewide average of 182 tickets per day.
- Lack of Clear Signage: Many drivers argued that there was no visible 40 mph speed limit sign in the work zone, with the first sign encountered by drivers indicating a 55 mph limit.
- Court Rulings Favoring Drivers: As cases were heard, the court began dismissing tickets based on discrepancies in photographic evidence and failure to notify drivers within the required timeframe.
- Judicial Insights: Judges noted inconsistencies between photos and videos presented as evidence, leading to multiple ticket dismissals.
- Advice for Future Cases: Drivers are advised to check for proper signage and ensure timely receipt of tickets to bolster their defense in court.
Detailed Breakdown
Discrepancies and Dismissals
The investigation revealed that many drivers were ticketed without clear indication of the reduced speed limit. For instance, Kevin Gee, who received six tickets, highlighted the absence of a 40 mph sign. Similarly, Reggie Dyche contended he was clocked at 55 mph, yet his argument was dismissed by the court. However, as the hearings progressed, the judges began to recognize the validity of the drivers’ claims regarding the missing signage.
Court Experiences
Several drivers shared their experiences in court. Ed Mattson had all his tickets dismissed due to late notification and photo discrepancies. Ken Andrews expressed relief after having four tickets thrown out, stating, “I hit the jackpot,” reflecting the sentiments of many drivers who felt wronged by the ticketing process.
Judicial Commentary
Judge LaMarr Jackson emphasized the importance of clear evidence, stating, “There is discrepancy with the photos and the video. They’re not even close.” This acknowledgment indicates a judicial willingness to question the integrity of the evidence presented by the DOT.
Notable Quotes & Data
- Kevin Gee: “I’ve had a clean record for 30 years,” expressing frustration over the six tickets received.
- Ken Andrews: “I hit the jackpot. All four dismissed,” highlighting the positive outcome for drivers as courts began to dismiss tickets.
- Judge LaMarr Jackson: “When you see a work zone you slow down,” underscoring the expectation of driver caution.
Context & Implications
The investigation sheds light on the broader implications of automated ticketing systems and their reliance on photographic evidence. The high volume of tickets raises questions about the adequacy of signage in work zones and the potential for systemic issues in the enforcement of speed limits. Furthermore, the dismissal of these tickets suggests that drivers may have a legitimate basis for contesting such charges, especially when evidence is inconsistent or notifications are delayed.
As more court cases are scheduled, the outcomes may lead to increased scrutiny of the DOT’s practices and potentially prompt changes in how speed limits are enforced in work zones. The ongoing discussions about fairness and transparency in traffic enforcement will likely resonate with drivers across New York State.